Using the Filesystem

Hey thank you fro the tuto, is it possible to change the upload destination directory from `public/uploads/` to somehting else !

Hey ahmedbhs

Of course it's possible =) Check out previous chapter it was configured there! https://symfonycasts.com/sc...

Cheers!

Just a small correction: You mentioned that the getPathname() method of the SplFileInfo class (or the Symfony File class) returns the absolute path to the file. This is not always true as getPathname() could return a relative path depending on how the file was instantiated. If you want to guarantee you get an absolute path, you should instead use the getRealPath() method.

All the file path/name naming conventions drive me crazy too haha.

Hey @jdevine!

GREAT note - I actually didn't realize that. These methods confuse the heck out of me - and I'm usually dd()'ing a few to find the one I want - that's almost definitely what I did here 😆

Cheers!

Hey there ,

I'm using "oneup/flysystem-bundle": "^4.0", and as Stephane mentioned, they removed the FilesystemInterface, and Diego suggested that we use League\Flysystem\FilesystemOperator but i got a few errors, first:

Cannot autowire service "App\Service\FileStorage": argument "$filesystemOperator" of method "__construct()" references interface "League\Flysystem\FilesystemOperator" but no such service exists. You sh <br /> ould maybe alias this interface to one of these existing services: "oneup_flysystem.mount_manager", "oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_filesystem_filesystem".

This happens when i've commented alias: League\Flysystem\Filesystem and with or without the bind $publicUploadsFilesystem: '@oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_filesystem_filesystem'

But if i remove the bind, and uncomment the alias, it works.

Hey Petru L.

As I see you try to bind $publicUploadsFilesystem: '@oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_filesystem_filesystem'
but in your App\Service\FileStorage you are using FilesystemOperator $filesystemOperator?

You should use FilesystemOperator $publicUploadsFilesystem in your App\Service\FileStorage::__constructor() to get bind work correctly

Cheers!

yeah... i don't know how i've missed that, i must have been tired, sorry and thank you

Hey =) no problem! Keep asking questions it helps to learn and develop better apps!

Hi Team,
I try to use "oneup/flysystem-bundle": "^4.0" to manage upload image.
I can't find FilesystemInterface in this version. There is "FilesystemAdapter" with method write. But this method has 3 parameters. The last is $config. What I have to use for this parameter ? I find nothing about that on bundle doc.
Cheers.

Hey Stephane

Yea, you're right. They dropped that interface in V2, I'm not aware of all the changes from V1 to V2 but it seems like you can rely on this other interface https://github.com/thephple...
although, some methods changed their signature, so if you find something not working as expected you may want to check this guide https://flysystem.thephplea...
and perhaps the CHANGELOG of the repository

Cheers!

Hey MolloKhan,

Thank you for your reply.

I succeeded to use the oneup/flysystem-bundle with FilesystemOperator interface.
When I use the command symfony console debug:container flysystem, I don't have "oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_filesystem_filesystem".
In the list there are 23 results with "oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_adapter_adapter" but not implement FilesystemInterface
There is "oneup_flysystem.default_filesystem_filesystem" and I use it and it's works until chapter 17.

I use {{ photo.imagePath|imagine_filter('image_thumb') }} after I config the loaders and data_loader into liip_imagine.yaml file and no thumbnail is created.

When I {{ dump(photo.imagePath) }} I have "trick_image/dscn2936-5d2df5309722a-60410d4c2fc3a.jpg".
The value of src of img markup is : https://localhost:8000/media/cache/resolve/image_thumb/trick_image/dscn2936-5d2df5309722a-60410d4c2fc3a.jpg

I don't see any solution. If you have some advice to check something.

Cheers.

What version of the LiipImagine bundle are you using? They added support to Flysystem V2 not to long ago. Check this pull request https://github.com/liip/Lii...
and here's an issue about it https://github.com/liip/Lii...

Thank for these links.
I use LiipImagine bundle version 2.5.0
For you, it is better to use https://github.com/thephple... that https://github.com/1up-lab/... ?

Hey @Stéphane!

Hmm. The phpleague one didn’t exist when I created this tutorial, but I think it will become / is the official solution (though both are great) and the phpleague one is built by a friend of mine that I trust.

In both cases, you’re still working with Flysystem under the hood. The bundles are a glue config layer. So you can almost just read the docs of each and choose the one with the config you like better :).

Cheers!

Hello team and thanks for the tutorial,

I'm stuck in this part, in the method

uploadArticleImage -> i got an error when i try to upload a image because is waitng UploadedFile, if i change the method with the UploadedFile no error but the image is not in the folder.

my method in uploadHelper:

public function uploadArticleImage(UploadedFile $file): string
{
$originalFileName = pathinfo($file->getClientOriginalName(), PATHINFO_FILENAME);
$newFilename = $originalFileName . '-' . uniqid() . '.' . $file->guessExtension();

$stream = fopen($file->getPathname(), 'r');
$this->filesystem->writeStream(
self::ARTICLE_IMAGE.'/'.$newFilename,
$stream
);
if (is_resource($stream)) {
fclose($stream);
}

return $newFilename;
}

the method in my controller:

/**
* @Route("/admin/editArticle/{id}", name="edit_article")
*/
public function editArticle(Request $request, Article $article, UploaderHelper $uploaderHelper){
$form = $this->createForm(ArticleFromType::class, $article);
$form->handleRequest($request);

if ( $form->isSubmitted() && $form->isValid()) {
$article = $form->getData();

/**
* @var UploadedFile $uploadedFile
*/
$uploadedFile = $form['imageFile']->getData();

if ($uploadedFile){
$newFileName = $uploaderHelper->uploadArticleImage($uploadedFile);
$article->setImageFileName($newFileName);
}

$this->em->persist($article);
$this->em->flush();

return $this->redirectToRoute('list_article');
}

return $this->render('admin/articles/addArticle.html.twig', [
'articleForm' => $form->createView(),
]);
}

thanks!

I solved...

Was the oneup_flysystem.yaml, i wrote wrong the destination.

Sorry

I'm glad to hear that you could fix your problem. Keep it going :)

Thank you guys for the great work as usual awesome idea and a wealth of learning. I was just wondering how do we fix auto-wiring issue using the first method i.e.

we could re-add the alias option and point it at this FilesystemInterface.

Hey Abdul,

We show this in the video, I updated the script and added the missing code block in case you only read scripts:
https://github.com/knpunive...

We also talk about aliases in the previous video: https://symfonycasts.com/sc... - you may want to check it.

Cheers!

Hi,

great tutorial but I get the following error while binding : `$publicUploadsFilesystem` parameter to '@oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_filesystem_filesystem'` service:

The service "App\Service\UploaderHelper"has a dependency on a non-existent service "oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_filesystem_filesystem"

I finally solve it moving the oneup config block into the main`services.yaml` file:

# Read the documentation: https://github.com/1up-lab/...
oneup_flysystem:
adapters:
public_uploads_adapter:
local:
directory: '%kernel.project_dir%/public/uploads'
filesystems:
public_uploads_filesystem:
adapter: public_uploads_adapter

Any idea, why ? Is this a an issue with the processing of separate configuration file with sf4 and oneup bundle?
Cheers,
ben

Hey Benoît M.

Hm, that's strange. Have you tried to debug it with php bin/console debug:container and search there oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_filesystem_filesystem service? Probably bundle is not configured properly, maybe a typo in config or somewhere else. Also you can use php bin/console debug:config <bundleName> to see if it's configured as needed

Cheers!

Hi @Vladimir Sadicov,
no typo: I am cutting/pasting the following block from `config/packages/oneup_flysystem.yaml` to the end of `config/services.yaml`:

# Read the documentation: https://github.com/1up-lab/...
oneup_flysystem:
adapters:
public_uploads_adapter:
local:
directory: '%kernel.project_dir%/public/uploads'
filesystems:
public_uploads_filesystem:
adapter: public_uploads_adapter

When the block is set in `config/services.yaml`, I can run any command line like:

php bin/console debug:container public_uploads_filesystem

=>

Information for Service "oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_filesystem_filesystem"
==============================================================================

---------------- -------------------------------------------------------------
Option Value
---------------- -------------------------------------------------------------
Service ID oneup_flysystem.public_uploads_filesystem_filesystem
Class League\Flysystem\Filesystem
Tags oneup_flysystem.filesystem (key: public_uploads_filesystem)
Public yes
Synthetic no
Lazy no
Shared yes
Abstract no
Autowired no
Autoconfigured no
---------------- -------------------------------------------------------------

The `php bin/console debug:config oneup_flysystem` returns:

Current configuration for extension with alias "oneup_flysystem"
================================================================

oneup_flysystem:
adapters:
default_adapter:
local:
directory: /var/www/app/var/cache/dev/flysystem
lazy: false
writeFlags: 2
linkHandling: 2
permissions:
file:
public: 420
private: 384
dir:
public: 493
private: 448
public_uploads_adapter:
local:
directory: /var/www/app/public/uploads
lazy: false
writeFlags: 2
linkHandling: 2
permissions:
file:
public: 420
private: 384
dir:
public: 493
private: 448
filesystems:
default_filesystem:
adapter: default_adapter
alias: League\Flysystem\Filesystem
disable_asserts: false
plugins: { }
cache: null
mount: null
public_uploads_filesystem:
adapter: public_uploads_adapter
disable_asserts: false
plugins: { }
cache: null
alias: null
mount: null
cache: { }

cheers,
ben

Nice can you try same commands with default config place inside config/packages/oneup_flysystem.yaml, but remove var binding to not produce an error, also better check will be php bin/console debug:container oneup_flysystem to see all registered services

Cheers!

done, here is the output :

php bin/console debug:container oneup_flysystem

Select one of the following services to display its information:
[0 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.local
[1 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.nulladapter
[2 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_fac...
[3 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.async_aws_s3
[4 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.awss3v2
[5 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.awss3v3
[6 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.azureblob
[7 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.dropbox
[8 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.googlecloudstorage
[9 ] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.rackspace
[10] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.webdav
[11] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.ftp
[12] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.sftp
[13] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.gridfs
[14] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.customadapter
[15] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.memory
[16] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.fallback
[17] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.gaufrette
[18] oneup_flysystem.adapter_factory.replicate
[19] oneup_flysystem.cache_factory.adapter
[20] oneup_flysystem.cache_factory.memory
[21] oneup_flysystem.cache_factory.noop
[22] oneup_flysystem.cache_factory.memcached
[23] oneup_flysystem.cache_factory.php_redis
[24] oneup_flysystem.cache_factory.predis
[25] oneup_flysystem.cache_factory.stash
[26] oneup_flysystem.cache_factory.psr6
[27] oneup_flysystem.adapter.local
[28] oneup_flysystem.adapter.cached
[29] oneup_flysystem.adapter.nulladapter
[30] oneup_flysystem.adapter.memory
[31] oneup_flysystem.adapter.zip
[32] oneup_flysystem.adapter.async_aws_s3
[33] oneup_flysystem.adapter.awss3v2
[34] oneup_flysystem.adapter.awss3v3
[35] oneup_flysystem.adapter.azureblob
[36] oneup_flysystem.adapter.dropbox
[37] oneup_flysystem.adapter.googlecloudstorage
[38] oneup_flysystem.adapter.rackspace
[39] oneup_flysystem.adapter.webdav
[40] oneup_flysystem.adapter.ftp
[41] oneup_flysystem.adapter.sftp
[42] oneup_flysystem.adapter.gridfs
[43] oneup_flysystem.adapter.fallback
[44] oneup_flysystem.adapter.gaufrette
[45] oneup_flysystem.adapter.replicate
[46] oneup_flysystem.mount_manager
[47] oneup_flysystem.filesystem
[48] oneup_flysystem.cache.adapter
[49] oneup_flysystem.cache.memory
[50] oneup_flysystem.cache.noop
[51] oneup_flysystem.cache.memcached
[52] oneup_flysystem.cache.predis
[53] oneup_flysystem.cache.php_redis
[54] oneup_flysystem.cache.stash
[55] oneup_flysystem.cache.psr6
[56] oneup_flysystem.plugin.empty_dir
[57] oneup_flysystem.plugin.get_with_metadata
[58] oneup_flysystem.plugin.list_files
[59] oneup_flysystem.plugin.list_paths
[60] oneup_flysystem.plugin.list_with
[61] oneup_flysystem.default_adapter_adapter
[62] oneup_flysystem.default_filesystem_filesystem

Awesome! One more output please php bin/console debug:config oneup_flysystem

for sure:

php bin/console debug:config oneup_flysystem

Current configuration for extension with alias "oneup_flysystem"
================================================================

oneup_flysystem:
adapters:
default_adapter:
local:
directory: /var/www/app/var/cache/dev/flysystem
lazy: false
writeFlags: 2
linkHandling: 2
permissions:
file:
public: 420
private: 384
dir:
public: 493
private: 448
filesystems:
default_filesystem:
adapter: default_adapter
alias: League\Flysystem\Filesystem
disable_asserts: false
plugins: { }
cache: null
mount: null
cache: { }

Bingo, now we see that your config file is not loaded at all and that's weird. Let's check configs now it should be like this:
config/packages/oneup_flysystem.yaml``

oneup_flysystem:

adapters:
    public_uploads_adapter:
        local:
            directory: '%kernel.project_dir%/public/uploads'
filesystems:
    public_uploads_filesystem:
        adapter: public_uploads_adapter

check the indentation and `dev/` folders another tip is try to clear cache but just delete cache folders not via console command

Hey best team !

when i load fixtures i got this error: File already exists at path: article_image/lightspeed

i removed the uploads directory and also dropped the database but nothing changed,

`
<?php
namespace App\Service;

use Gedmo\Sluggable\Util\Urlizer;
use League\Flysystem\FilesystemInterface;
use Symfony\Component\HttpFoundation\File\File;
use Symfony\Component\HttpFoundation\File\UploadedFile;

class UploaderHelper
{

const ARTICLE_IMAGES = 'article_image';

private $filesystem;
public function __construct(FilesystemInterface $publicUploadsFilesystem)
{
    $this->filesystem = $publicUploadsFilesystem;
}

public function uploadArticleImage(File $file): string

{
    if($file instanceof UploadedFile){
        $getOriginalName = $file->getClientOriginalName();
    }else{
        $getOriginalName = $file->getFilename();
    }
    $newFilename = Urlizer::urlize(pathinfo($getOriginalName, PATHINFO_FILENAME));

    $this->filesystem->write(
        self::ARTICLE_IMAGES.'/'.$newFilename,
        file_get_contents($file->getPathname())
    );
    return $newFilename;
}

public function getPublicPath(string $path): string {
  return '/uploads/'. $path;

}
}

`

I'm enjoying so much this course!

I appreciate your help !

Hey Raed!

Glad you're enjoying the course! But I'm sorry you're having trouble at this spot! Let's see if we can figure it out.

So, you said that you get this "File already exists at path" when you load the fixtures? Hmm, I think that's coming from Flysystem. And the error says "article_image/lightspeed" is the filename... which doesn't contain a file extension of any unique part of the URL. I would look at UploadHelper - it should (at this point in the tutorial) add a random string to the filename so that it's always unique. You can see us doing this on this code block: https://symfonycasts.com/screencast/symfony-uploads/fixtures-uploading#codeblock-c317fd7c09&#039;

Let me know what you find out! I think there is something wrong with the $newFilename part of the code.

Cheers!

Hey weaverryan,

Thank you so much for your help!

I don't how i missed out that uniqid part :-) Its working now after adding it, Thanks again !

Hey great tuts! btw could you pls tell how to get the url of the uploaded file on local/s3 storage?

Hi Tanvir mahmud R.!

Thanks :). Getting the URL to the uploaded file can be tricky - but we talk about it in various parts of this tutorial. Try checking out these:

* https://symfonycasts.com/sc...
* https://symfonycasts.com/sc...
* https://symfonycasts.com/sc...
* https://symfonycasts.com/sc...

Let me know if those help!

Cheers!